It takes some trial and error, but Woodstock manages to build himself a nice bird's nest up in his small tree. Then, while playing around in the birdbath, he gets caught up in a bad thunderstorm but is saved by Snoopy, who gets him out of the bath and dries off his soaked feathers (before mischievously blowing him into his water bowl). Meanwhile, Sally complains about being assigned yet another science project by her teacher, whom she's convinced has a personal vendetta against her. This time, the project has to be something from nature, and Sally is determined not to crack under the pressure and deliver an exhibit that will knock her teacher's socks off. That evening, Woodstock returns to his tree, only to find that his nest is gone. He promptly informs Snoopy of this and Snoopy, in turn, after spying some footprints leading away from the tree, dresses up as Sherlock Holmes and helps Woodstock search for his missing nest. For them, everybody in the neighborhood is a potential suspect, and they go from house to house, interrogating them, and sometimes wishing they hadn't. But even when they track down the culprit, as well as find the nest, they may not be able to take it back without a fight... real or "legal."
This was during the period I've mentioned where, after directing all of the previous Peanuts specials, Bill Melendez took on more of a producing role while directing other projects. In his stead, Phil Roman, who'd worked in the animation department on some of the past ones, as well as the two feature films, and had co-directed A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving with Melendez the previous year, made his solo directorial debut with this one. Of course, he would go on to direct a good number of them over the course of the next ten years, with his last solo one being 1983's Is This Goodbye, Charlie Brown? He would also direct some parts of It's an Adventure, Charlie Brown that same year, but by that point, he'd begun directing the Garfield specials and would soon break away from Melendez and Lee Mendelson, who produced the first two of those cartoons, to form Film Roman to continue making them.
Although the special begins with Woodstock, and the "mystery" at the center of the story is all about him, Snoopy is as much of a main character as he is. After a momentary hitch in building his nest, as he falls right through the bottom when he steps into it, Woodstock manages to construct it in a manner where it's totally secure. Satisfied, he then goes for a dip in his birdbath, only to run into major trouble when a strong thunderstorm kicks up and turns the bath into violent rapids that nearly drown him. But when Snoopy comes by, you see that it's actually not nearly as bad as it seemed to Woodstock. Still, Snoopy scoops him out of the birdbath and puts him on top of his doghouse (he really should've taken Woodstock inside, as he sits atop the house, shivering), when the rain stops and the sun comes back out. Snoopy then takes out a blow dryer and dries Woodstock's feathers... only for him to then use the force of the dryer to blow him off the roof and into his water bowl. Despite this, when sunset comes around, Woodstock is dried and content, and heads back to his little tree, only to then discover that his nest is gone. He promptly throws a fit about it, which catches Snoopy's attention, and when he tells him what's going on, Snoopy, noting some footprints leading away from the tree, decides to investigate. He goes full Sherlock Holmes, from the coat and hat, to the old-fashioned style of pipe (which, in this case, blows big bubbles rather than puffs of smoke, and which seem to gravitate towards Woodstock). The two of them go around the neighborhood, interrogating everybody from Charlie Brown himself to Linus and Lucy, Marcie, and Peppermint Patty. But they come away with no leads and most of the interrogations prove to be more trouble than they're worth. Snoopy then does what he should've done in the first place, which is actually follow the footprints he saw earlier, which lead them to the elementary school and Woodstock's nest, which is being housed in the science lab as an exhibit. They take the nest back and Snoopy puts it back in the tree, but the next day, Sally, who'd taken it for her school science project, is ready to literally fight both of them for it. Charlie Brown then opts to try to find someone objective to settle the manner... and that someone turns out to be Lucy.It's really entertaining, as well as impressive, how the animators get across Snoopy and Woodstock's personalities and mindsets purely through their facial expressions and movements. During the opening, when Woodstock is building his nest, he comes off like an actual bird, as he does when he's confused upon first discovering that his nest is missing, looking underneath the branch and on the opposite end for it. And yet, at the same time, he uses an apparent invisible elevator to go up and down the tree, and is rather cute when he's getting into the birdbath, splashing himself with water and testing its temperature, before getting into it full on. You also feel genuinely concerned for him when he's gettingthrashed around in the storm, especially as he squeaks in fear and quickly puts together a little raft that's almost immediately torn apart, and it's funny when he later rants about his missing nest to Snoopy. Speaking of Snoopy, despite being his usual mischievous self to Woodstock, you can still see the affection he has for his little buddy, with how he pats him on the head before sending him home after the storm and goes above and beyond to help him find his nest. You can also sense his ego and cockiness when he's dressed up as Sherlock Holmes and which repeatedly blow up in his face, as he's either literally thrown out by Lucy, gets nowhere with Marcie, or is chased around by Peppermint Patty, who thinks they're playing "cops
and robbers." All the while, Woodstock is little more than a butt monkey, as the bubbles from Snoopy's pipe repeatedly float towards and soak him when they burst upon touching him (he runs from one but it deliberately chases and absorbs him, before popping and soaking him anyway) or gets yanked through the mail slot in Marcie's door. When they track down the nest to the school, they run afoul of some of the bizarre science projects in the lab, before grabbing the nest and taking it back home. During the final act, when Lucy is asked to be the objective third party to resolve the conflict, it turns into a mock court case, with her as the judge and Snoopy donning his Joe Cool persona and acting as Woodstock's lawyer, presenting Lucy with documents that are full of
nearly intelligible, complex legal jargon. In the end, Lucy rules in favor of Snoopy and Woodstock, much to Sally's frustration. Snoopy agrees to act as a replacement science project, helping her recreate Ivan Pavlov's salivating dog experiment (he almost blows it for her by not immediately drooling when she rings the bell, like he's supposed to). Meanwhile, that hard-fought nest turns out to still not be perfect, as Woodstock falls through its bottom behind the opening credits.
Charlie Brown's (voiced by Todd Barbee) role here is minimal at best. In his first scene, he listens as Sally rants and raves about having to do another science project. He tries to console her, but she won't listen to anything he says, and when she storms out of the room, all he can do is groan, "Good grief!" He also happens to be the first one whom Snoopy and Woodstock interrogate about the missing nest. They literally sit him down and put a light on above him, but when he learns what the issue is, he tells them that he knows nothing about it and refuses to say anything else. But because of this, when Sally later claims that the "prehistoric bird's nest" she found and was using as a science exhibit was stolen from her, Charlie Brown realizes she was the one who took Woodstock's nest and tells her as much. He next has to stop Sally from getting into a fight with both Snoopy and Woodstock, and comes up with the idea of bringing in an objective third party. He takes them to Lucy, explains that, "It's a matter of establishing ownership," and that leads into the mock trial, which Snoopy and Woodstock win. And when Sally is enraged at this, Charlie Brown and Snoopy come up with an idea for a replacement science project.As in the past, Sally (voiced by Lynn Mortensen) complains about her schoolwork, telling her brother that science teacher has it out for her, whining, "Every week, she makes me bring in a new exhibit. I'm going to have a nervous breakdown before I'm six years old!... This week, it's gotta be something from nature. Why don't we leave nature alone?! It's not bothering us; why do we have to bother it?... But I'll show her. I won't crack! I refuse to crack! I'll get the best exhibit she's ever seen!" Said exhibit, of course, turns out to be Woodstock's nest, which Sally thought was prehistoric because it, "Was so ridiculous, it had to be prehistoric! No self-respecting modern bird could've built it!" And when the nest goes missing after Snoopy and Woodstock retrieve it, Sally rants and raves again: "I've been robbed! I've been bugged! I've been betrayed!... They're after me! They're all after me! Get my lawyer! Get my bookkeeper!... Get my accountant! Get my lawyer!" Even after Charlie Brown explains that it was Woodstock's nest, Sally goes with the classic, "Finders keepers, losers weepers," justification and sticks with it during the "trial," where she represents herself. When Lucy rules in favor of Snoopy and Woodstock, Sally screams, "I've been robbed! I appeal! I'll take it all the way to the Supreme Court!" She walks home with Charlie Brown, utterly defeated, but when he and Snoopy come up with an alternative for her science project, she's initially unwilling to use it. However, since she has no choice, she goes along with it. During her presentation in class, she first brings up Ivan Pavlov, saying he studied the human nervous system, and adding, "And you all know why we have a nervous system: so we can get nervous making these stupid reports!" In any case, she and Snoopy end the special by recreating the salivating dog experiment.When Snoopy and Woodstock show up at her and Linus' home, Lucy (voiced by Melanie Kohn) is immediately irked by Snoopy, as he takes her fingerprint, then kicks up a big cloud of dust while searching the living room for more fingerprints. When he finds a broom straw and tries to use it to implicate her, Lucy is unfazed. And when he then handcuffs her to his own wrist to try and arrest her, she drags him to the doorway, swings him around, and flings him with enough force to snap the chain and send him flying. Later, when Charlie Brown comes to her to resolve the conflict that Sally now has with Snoopy and Woodstock, Lucy turns her psychiatric booth into an outside courtroom, donning a judge's robe and powdered wig, while Linus acts as her stenographer. She also charges two cents more than her fee for psychiatric help and demands to be paid up front; when Charlie Brown tells her that she hasn't done anything, she says, "It's a well-known fact that silver in the scales of justice have great affinity." Naturally, she finds the trial to be very frustrating, especially when Snoopy's defense for Woodstock involves documents with tongue-twisting legal jargon, Sally just goes with, "Finders keepers, losers weepers," and Linus proves to be a lousy stenographer, as he hasn't taken down anything since Lucy declared that court was in session. Yet amazingly, Lucy not only sides with Woodstock but comes up with a sensible and fair reason for doing so: he built the nest, therefore it's his.Linus (voiced by Stephen Shea) only has three lines during the scene where Snoopy and Woodstock search his and Lucy's home for clues, and they're all random and similar non-sequiturs. "Ashes to ashes, and dust to dust. Snoopy will find it, and find it he must." "Ashes to ashes, and dust to dust. When there is a problem, in Snoopy, we trust." "Ashes to ashes, and dust to dust. The proof of the pudding is under the crust." That last one aggravates Lucy to the point where she lets out Charlie Brown's trademark, "Aaaugh!" scream at Linus, sending him tumbling backwards. And like I said, he's an awful stenographer. When Lucy tells him, "Stenographer, please read back the plaintiff's last statement," he fumbles his notes and admits, "Uh... Uh, actually, I just got past the 'oyez, oyez,' then, uh... What came after the oyez?'" To that, Lucy lets out another incredulous and annoyed, "Good grief."
Three other members of the Peanuts gang appear here, each when Snoopy and Woodstock show up at their respective houses. After the scene at Linus and Lucy's home, they next go to see Marcie (voiced by Jimmy Ahrens). Standing out on her front porch, Snoopy literally questions her, though she repeatedly tells him that she can't understand his inhuman muttering and finally slams the door on him. Unbeknownst to her, Woodstock wandered through the door while Snoopy was talking, and after she closes it, she's immediately questioned by him, until Snoopy reaches through the mail slot and pulls him through. They then go to see Pig-Pen (voiced by Tom Muller), who's the most accommodating to them, butthey can't tolerate all the dust he stirs up, especially when he walks out onto the porch and happily shakes Snoopy's hand, saying, "I haven't seen you for quite a while. How have you been?" They both choke on the cloud and decide not to even bother interrogating him. As they walk away, he calls out to them, "Nice talking to you! Come again! I don't have too many visitors!" And finally, they go see Peppermint Patty (voiced by Donna LeTourneau), which they really regret. At first confused by Snoopy's getup, she then thinks he's playing "cops and robbers." Wanting to play the robber, she puts on a mask and scares the crap out of him, as she jumps out and shouts at him (the sound of which is, again, that often used audio clip of Peter Robbins yelling from the original specials), cornering
him against the wall and saying, "Your money or your life, you dirty rat! Alright, copper. It's your money or you get cement shoes", in a faux James Cagney impression. Snoopy tries to fend her off, and the two of them get into a fight, only for Snoopy to take off running and Peppermint Patty to give chase, yelling, "Avast, ya lily-livered copper! You'll never take me alive!" (Yeah, she slipped into playing pirates there for a second.) "I don't squeal, copper! No one's takin' me in!" Snoopy and Woodstock run out the front door and into the night, while Patty stands on her front porch and, confused, takes off her mask and yells, "Hey, kid! Come back! We didn't finish the game! Come back, Snoop!"
I touched on the animation earlier, when I talked about Snoopy and Woodstock, and I'll go on to add that the animation throughout the cartoon is quite good. The first truly exceptional scene is when Woodstock is swimming around in the birdbath, when the storm suddenly builds up and he gets flung throughout the churning water. The shots of the clouds forming in the sky, the bolts of flashing lightning, a cutaway shot of some trees blowing in the wind, and the violent, rolling water that just about drowns Woodstock, all look really cool, and you have to admire the detail of Woodstock putting together a little raft amid the mayhem, using the twigs and leaves that get blown into the bath, only for that to almost immediately get destroyed. Like I said, I'msure that this animation was either reused or, at the very least, was the inspiration for a scene in the feature film, Race for Your Life, Charlie Brown, where the gang get caught up in a storm during the river race (the shot of the clouds building up and the violent water are especially similar). The character animation is also quite fluid in spots, be it when Snoopy is blow-drying Woodstock, when he's jumping up and down, ranting about his missing nest, when he shakes himself dry when he gets soaked by one of Snoopy's pipe bubbles (said bubbles are well animated in and of themselves), Lucy flings Snoopy around and around before literally throwing him out of her house, or especially when Peppermint Patty
chases around and fights Snoopy. In the scene where Snoopy and Woodstock track the nest down to the school's science lab, they play around with some other exhibits that they find, leading into some more notable instances of animation. There's one thing that waves around in such a way that watching it makes them both nauseated and they stagger away from it, green in the face. And then, Snoopy accidentally flips the switch on some sort of electrode device that shocks the living crap out of him. It not only zaps him up into the air and turns him into a fuzzball but, for a few frames, it turns him into a small, screaming skeleton (this is the only time I can think of the Peanuts adopting that classic cartoon gag), before he and Woodstock take off running! Seriously, if Woodstock weren't there, would you think that last screenshot was from a Peanuts cartoon?I hate that I wasn't able to find a rip of the remastered version of this special that was in that DVD set but, even without it, I can still say that, yet again, the backgrounds and environments are very nice to look at, especially since much this one is set outside. The opening shot, panning over to Charlie Brown's house amid the trees, before zooming in to the little one where Woodstock builds his nest, is quite lovely, and there are a good number of nice dusk and nighttime exterior scenes, the former of which not only have a pretty pink sky in the background but also have some purple and blue mixed within some shots, while the latter often have a nice background made up of a gray, cloudy sky with a full moon, as well as the surrounding neighborhood in some instances. As forinteriors, the most memorable home is Peppermint Patty's, mostly due to its bright pink color scheme, as well as the furniture and potted plant that she uses to sneak up on and jump out at Snoopy, and this big, winding staircase she chases him down (which seems to have a picture of a Royal Canadian Mounty on the wall). And then, there's the school, which we've seen before, obviously, but here, we get to see not only the fairly detailed science lab but also some rather interesting exhibits that Snoopy and Woodstock blunder into before they take back the nest. They first come upon this device with a microphone that registers sound-waves on a monitor in front of it, and while Snoopy is impressed with it, Woodstock is
more intent in getting his nest back and rants at him for wasting time playing with it. Second is this machine that stretches and whirls around this pink material akin to taffy, the sight of which gives the two of them motion sickness, and after that is when Snoopy gets zapped by that electrode machine. The only major technical flaw with this aspect of the cartoon is, when Sally is about ready to fight Snoopy and Woodstock on the sidewalk, there's a shot where Charlie Brown is standing behind Sally, as she and Snoopy are putting up their dukes, and there's no background other than the sky, so it looks like they're floating in midair. Back when Paramount put the
special on VHS, they fixed this error by tightly zooming in on this scene, but on the Peanuts 1970's Collection Volume One set, it's left unaltered, as you can see right here. (In case you're wondering why I didn't just get my images from this source, that's because this screenshot is from a YouTube video that lists the special's soundtrack and also illustrates what scenes they appear in onscreen, so the number of specific images is a bit limited.)Like Play It Again, Charlie Brown, the biggest personal issue I have with It's a Mystery is the story, specifically the mystery itself. I wish there was more to it, and that the investigation, as it were, took longer, with Snoopy and Woodstock having to search farther for the missing nest, getting themselves into even stranger and crazier predicaments. But, not only do they find it ten minutes before the special is over, but you know right off the bat who the culprit is, as the scene where Sally complains about her science project and expresses her determination not to let her teacher get the best of her comes right before Woodstock discovers that his nest is missing. And then, after they find it, they get into that dispute over who owns it, and while it is funny to see Lucy changeher psychiatric booth into a "court of legal aid," dress up as a judge, and have to deal with the mass of legal gobbledygook that is Snoopy's documentation of Woodstock's case and Linus' awful performance as a stenographer, as well as shocking that she not only rules in Woodstock's favor but that it's a fair and reasonable decision, I wish they would've just added to the mystery itself instead. Yeah, I'm nitpicking, and most of the Peanuts cartoons aren't known for being the pinnacle of animated storytelling anyway (I do think this special is stronger on that score than Play It Again, though), but the mystery angle is what intrigues me the most here and I just wanted more done with it.
Little Birdie, a song that Vince Guaraldi himself sang for the previous Peanuts special, A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving, is reused a couple of times in the score for It's a Mystery as an instrumental. In fact, it's the first piece you hear at the very beginning, when Woodstock is building his nest, and is played again when he discovers that his nest is gone. Similarly, an instrumental version of Joe Cool, specifically a brass version with Guaraldi whistling, is used when Snoopy first puts himself forward as Woodstock's lawyer. As for the original music here, there are two tracks that have the word "mystery" in their official titles. One, just called Mystery, is this electric guitar theme that first plays after Woodstock has fallen through his nest at the beginning and plays a number of times throughout the cartoon, notably when he and Snoopy are going to the various houses, as well as during the ending credits. (This piece of music would be reworked for the very next special, It's the Easter Beagle, Charlie Brown, which aired just two months later.) Another theme, which has the same title as the cartoon itself, is this upbeat piece of music that's first heard when Woodstock successfully builds his nest and goes down to his birdbath, and is heard in various versions throughout. It was also slowed down to act as a melancholic theme for Sally, both in the scene where she's complaining about her science project and at the end, when she gives her presentation. Speaking of Sally, a particularly downtrodden, bluesy theme, fittingly called Sally's Blues, plays when she rants about her science project being stolen. There's also a theme called Cops and Robbers, which also plays when Snoopy and Woodstock are going around the neighborhood, but really goes into full swing during the scene with Peppermint Patty.
It's a Mystery, Charlie Brown is another Peanuts special that lacks a bit in terms of story, but in this case, it more than makes up for it with some really great animation, especially for the two leads of Snoopy and Woodstock and in specific scenes, most of the other characters here get their respective times to shine, some genuinely funny and even wild moments, a surprising resolution, and some more memorable music. It is a shame that the mystery wasn't focused on or developed a little more, or that the culprit was all but revealed at the very start, but in the end, that doesn't stop this one from still being fairly enjoyable, especially for big Snoopy and Woodstock fans.